Apple Watch Series 4 vs Garmin Fenix 5 Plus: Which is Best?


If you want to get a ​top-notch smartwatch in 2019, you can’t go wrong with either the Apple Watch Series 4 or Garmin Fenix 5 Plus.

You might be hesitant to make a choice between them, so in this article, we’ll spare you the time and effort by comparing the two and determining which one beats the other.

Apple Watch 4 vs Garmin Fenix 5 Plus: Specs Compared


Apple Watch 4

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus

Release Date

September 2018June 2018

Battery Life

18 hoursSmartwatch: 12 days. GPS: 18 hours.


40mm or 44mm47 x 47 x 15.8 mm


1.69 ounces3 ounces or 2.6 ounces on the Titanium version


LTE and UMTS, GPS, WiFi 802.11b/g/n 2.4GHz, Bluetooth 5.0Bluetooth®, ANT+®, Wi-Fi®


Calls, texts, and appsCalls, texts, apps

Water Resistance

Resists water up to 5 ATM10 ATM


Through Apple MusicControl music from connected phone

Platform Support

iOSAndroid, iOS with limitations

Virtual Assistant


Customer Reviews




Apple Watch 4 Overview

Apple Watch vs Garmin Fenix


  • Powerful S4 processing chip
  • System in package technology
  • Satisfactory combination between smart, fitness, and health features


  • Substandard battery life
  • Relatively expensive

With all the helpful fitness, health, and smart features of the Apple Watch and improved technology, the Apple Watch Series 4 is really the best in its line. It also has a stylish look and is comfortable to wear, but may be a little pricey.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus Overview



  • Great design and display
  • Accurate sensors
  • Solid battery life
  • Very customisable


  • Software stuttering when overloaded
  • Screen resolution isn’t that good

The Garmin Fenix 5 Plus is a great smartwatch as it delivers a lot of great functions at an affordable price, which makes it a good bang for your buck.

Apple Watch Series 4 vs Garmin Fenix 5 Plus Comparison

Apple Watch vs Garmin Fenix: Design and Display

Apple Watch Series 4:

Both the Apple Watch Series models boast great resolutions with LTPO technology that makes the Series 4 more power-efficient and gets you through the day, be it the 40mm model with the 394 x 324-pixels on a 1.17-inch display or the 44mm model with the 448 x 368-pixel on the 1.15-inch display.With narrower borders that still give you a 30% larger viewing area, it has successfully overcome the challenge of reducing the watch’s size while maintaining the compactness of the case and the battery life. And despite being around 30% smaller in size, the Series 4 integrates 21% more components thanks to the System in Package (SiP) technology that was applied to it. You can easily navigate through the watch with the turn of the Digital Crown.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus:

With a bright, high-resolution (240 x 240-pixels), full-color Garmin Chroma Display on a 1.2-inch screen, reading the info from your Fenix 5 Plus will be very easy. Add to that the LED backlighting and readability is guaranteed in all ambient conditions.The transflective technology enables it to reflect and transmit light at the same time so that the display is still visible in bright sunlight.Whether you choose the sapphire or reinforced glass, you’re going to get a titanium metal bezel and your choice of silicon, metal, or leather strap.

Winner: The Apple Watch Series 4.

Fenix 5 vs Apple Watch 4: Durability and Build

Apple Watch Series 4:

You can get the Apple Watch Series 4 in durable aluminum or stainless steel. Taking a shower or hopping into the pool doesn’t mean you have to take it off as it’s water-resistant up to 165 feet. It’s not very customizable as you are limited the clock faces that it has and its straps aren’t interchangeable.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus:

The Garmin Fenix 5 Plus has a rugged design to handle all the adventures you’re going to take on. From its finest premium-grade materials to the scratch resistance and high-strength domed sapphire lens, nothing is going to beat your Fenix 5.It’s available in different finish choices including PVD-coated stainless steel bezel and DLC titanium bezel models.The Fenix 5 Plus is water-resistant up to 10 ATM or 330 feet.

Winner: The Garmin Fenix 5 Plus.

Fitness and Health Features

Apple Watch Series 4:

Whether you’re doing yoga or hiking, your Apple Watch Series 4 is going to automatically detect different kinds of workouts. It keeps track of your progress while it displays 5 metrics including the distance you’ve walked and the calories you’ve burned.The 3 rings that signify exercising, standing, and moving are a great motivation as they send you reminders to make progress with them and close them. It’s a nice touch that resembles a challenge with yourself and makes you bent on closing the circles every day. If you want to up your challenges, the Apple Watch Series 4 also has head-to-head competitions, activity-sharing, personalized coaching, monthly challenges, and achievement rewards to motivate you to be more active.It has an electrical and optical heart rate sensor so its monitoring is pretty accurate. It notifies you if there is any irregularity such as your heart rate exceeding or falling short of a specified threshold that lasts for more than 10 minutes.The detailed sleep-tracking gives you feedback on the duration you’ve spent in each sleep stage (REM, light, and deep sleep) and thereby the quality of your sleep.Apple has also stated that its Series 4 is able to detect if you’ve fallen and are unable to get up and in effect sends an Emergency SOS.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus:

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus watches come with a built-in altimeter, barometer, and compass. The altimeter works on recognizing your ascent and descent to detect activities like hiking. It also tracks the number of floors you’ve climbed.

The tilt-compensated three-axis electronic compass maintains your bearing, regardless of whether you’re moving or not.The Garmin Fenix 5 Plus truly helps you push your limits. With a simple tap, you can get physiological metrics, running dynamics, track your workout stats, measure your progress, and fine-tune your performance. It has a training status that automatically evaluates your recent exercise history and performance indicators to give you an insight on whether you’re overtraining, maintaining, or peaking. You’re also able to view your overall training load which shows you the exercise volume from the last week and compares it to the optimal range for your fitness and recent history of training.Some special preloaded activity profiles are available such as profiles for swimming, running, biking, skiing, hiking, paddle boarding, rowing, and more!Through the Garmin Connect app, you can also download advanced workouts and training plans for an extra challenge and added motivation.The heart rate monitoring is available thanks to Elevate wrist heart rate technology without needing a chest strap. The Fenix 5 Plus uses the information from the calories you’ve burned to quantify the intensity of your fitness activities.You get your steps counted, your sleep monitored, and your heart rate variability calculated for a stress score that helps you evaluate the level of activity your body is ready to handle.For added metrics and a more solid background on your workouts, you can download the Running Power app from the Connect IQ store. This brilliant addition –developed by Garmin Labs- gives you extended metrics such as pace, vertical oscillation, grade, and even local wind conditions to give you an accurate estimation of the power you’re exerting as you run. This helps you assess yourself better when it comes to your pace and stamina. If you already have the HRM-Run, HRM-Tri, or the Running Dynamic Pod, adding power to your run will be free.

Winner: Garmin Fenix 5 Plus.

Apple Watch 4 or Fenix 5 Plus: Smart Features

Apple Watch Series 4

There’s not one inch on the Apple Watch Series 4 that isn’t used to give you some sort of info. This includes an index for Air Quality, Ultra Violet rays, heart rate, activity, music, workout, breath, and weather.The Walkie Talkie feature is a nice addition that brings you closer with other Apple Watch users. The relocation of the microphone to the opposite side to reduce the echoes makes the calls clearer. Add to that the fact that the speakers were made 50% more powerful, larger, and loaded and you get the clearest communication.The WatchOS 5 that runs the Apple Watch is very developed and fast. There’s also a raise-to-speak movement for Siri. This is especially useful in situations where your hands are busy like when you’re cycling or too sweaty like when you’re working out vigorously, and find it hard to use the touchscreen.The S4 chip on the Apple Watch Series 4 makes its processing speed unprecedently fast with the 4th generation CPU that is twice as fast as rivals’. The SiP technology enables it to pack a powerful system with a lot of technology into a single component. The ability to perform with no lag or slow response is impressive, especially when you consider its compactness.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus

You’ll get to experience navigation at its best with the built-in mapping and navigation features that the Garmin Fenix 5 Plus integrates to keep you well-oriented.

It flaunts a full-color TOPO mapping and comes with preloaded map data that gives you all the information you need to easily find your way around at a glance. There’s also Trendline popularity routing that uses data from Garmin Connect to help you find the best routes and paths if you’re a runner or a cyclist.Not only does the Garmin Fenix 5 Plus use GPS, but it also works with GLONASS and Galileo to give you multinetwork satellite reception so that you’re never lost. The Garmin Fenix 5 Plus has the capacity to store up to 500 songs so that you can play your favorite workout music without needing your phone.Transferring music from your computer to the watch is very easy, and so is connecting compatible headphones.You can make payments with a wave of your wrist with the Garmin Pay contactless payment solution. This leaves you with more space of leaving your phone and wallet behind and thereby leaving your home without packing your pockets.When you pair your Fenix 5 Plus with a compatible device, you’ll get all the smart notifications you need. This includes e-mails, texts, and alerts. The Garmin Connect and Garmin Connect Mobile applications also make automatic uploads to the Garmin Connect online fitness community, live tracking, GroupTrack, and social media sharing.There’s a large degree of customization thanks to the watch faces, data fields, apps and widgets available on the Connect IQ store. You also get a vast array of choices between the QuickFit bands including premium leather, metal, or silicone.

This allows you to match your watch to any style, be it formal or sportive.

Winner: The Garmin Fenix 5 Plus.

Battery Life and Price

Apple Watch Series 4:

Compared to other smartwatches on the market of the same price or even less, the Apple Watch Series 4 offers a very short battery life. It only lasts 18 hours, which is the same as its predecessor: The Apple Watch Series 3.It’s compatible with iOS devices and will give you the best performance when you connect it to a compatible iPhone.Even though it isn’t a cheap option, it does offer you great technologies, high-quality components, and performance that you wouldn’t otherwise find for a cheaper price.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus:

The battery life on the Garmin Fenix 5 Plus is variable but impressive in all the choices. At its best, you can get an astounding 12-day battery life if you use it on smartwatch mode. With GPS, you can get up to 18 hours. With GPS and music, you get up to 8 hours.There’s an UltraTrac mode that prioritizes location tracking over other processes and extends your battery life to 42 hours.It’s a bit more expensive than the Apple Watch Series 4, but the price difference is quite justified when you bear all the ways the Fenix 5 beats the Series 4.Winner: Tie.

Garmin Fenix 5 Plus vs Apple Watch Series 4: Verdict

Even though at first glance, it seems that the Garmin Fenix 5 Plus is an easy winner, you have to bear in mind the quite large difference in price.

Both choices aren’t the most budget-friendly options you can go for, but the Apple Watch Series 4’s seems proportionate with the smart technology and various features it delivers.

And although the Fenix 5 Plus has a lot to offer, it seems like it’s a more suitable choice for someone who is a hardcore sports enthusiast, a professional, or an athlete. If you are one, you won’t find a better fitness tracker.

If not, then the Apple Watch Series 4 might seem like the more balanced choice that will still provide you with everything you need.